Viola Davis: Unearthing the Power of the Everyday Actor

The Oscar-winning actress champions the art of portraying ordinary lives, challenging Hollywood’s gaze and redefining cinematic heroism.

In the glittering, often insular world of Hollywood, where larger-than-life characters and aspirational narratives frequently dominate the screen, Viola Davis’s poignant acceptance speech at the 89th Academy Awards for her supporting role in Fences served as a profound reminder of art’s capacity to illuminate the lives of ordinary people. Her powerful assertion that she was a “storyteller” and that her mother, often overlooked, was “the most extraordinary person” she ever knew, resonated far beyond the Dolby Theatre. Davis’s message was not merely an acknowledgment of her mother’s personal significance but a larger manifesto for a more inclusive and representative form of storytelling, one that dares to “exhume the ordinary.” This long-form article delves into the multifaceted impact of Davis’s call to arms, exploring its roots, its implications for the film industry, and its enduring relevance in a landscape still grappling with what constitutes a compelling narrative and who deserves to be its protagonist.

Davis’s speech was delivered at a pivotal moment in Hollywood, a time when discussions around diversity and representation were gaining significant momentum, yet tangible shifts in the industry’s storytelling priorities were still nascent. Her own career, marked by a consistent dedication to portraying complex, often marginalized characters, has long been a testament to her commitment to this artistic philosophy. From her groundbreaking role in The Help, which brought the nuanced experiences of Black domestic workers to a mainstream audience, to her commanding performance as Annalise Keating in How to Get Away with Murder, Davis has consistently elevated characters who defy simplistic categorization and whose struggles and triumphs are rooted in relatable human experience.

Context & Background: The Landscape of Storytelling Before and During Davis’s Ascent

For decades, Hollywood has, by and large, gravitated towards narratives featuring the extraordinary—superheroes, political titans, daring adventurers, and those born into privilege or possessing exceptional talents. The “ordinary” person, the everyday individual navigating the mundane yet often profound challenges of life, was frequently relegated to supporting roles, plot devices, or was simply absent from the cinematic canvas. This tendency was not born of malicious intent but rather a confluence of market forces, established narrative conventions, and a historical tendency to prioritize characters whose lives seemed inherently more dramatic or aspirational for a broad audience. The prevailing wisdom often suggested that audiences craved escape and spectacle, leading to a proliferation of stories that distanced viewers from their own lived realities.

The concept of the “hero’s journey,” a narrative archetype popularized by Joseph Campbell, often centers on a protagonist who embarks on an extraordinary adventure, facing trials and ultimately achieving a transformed state. While this framework can be applied to a wide range of stories, its emphasis on the exceptional has, in practice, often translated into a focus on individuals with inherent or acquired advantages. Characters grappling with systemic inequalities, the quiet dignity of labor, or the internal battles of everyday life were less likely to fit this mold without significant adaptation.

However, parallel to this dominant trend, a counter-movement was always present, championed by filmmakers and artists who understood the inherent drama and universal resonance of ordinary lives. Independent cinema, in particular, has historically provided a platform for these stories, allowing for more intimate explorations of the human condition. The rise of streaming services and changing audience demographics in the 21st century began to amplify these voices, creating a more fertile ground for narratives that challenged the status quo.

Viola Davis’s career trajectory intersects precisely with this evolving landscape. Her emergence as a leading lady, commanding leading roles that are both critically acclaimed and commercially successful, signaled a potential paradigm shift. Her Fences performance, based on August Wilson’s seminal play, was a masterclass in portraying the complexities of Rose Maxson, a woman whose life, while rooted in the struggles of a Black family in the mid-20th century, was ultimately defined by her quiet strength, unwavering love, and profound internal resilience. The role itself was a testament to Wilson’s genius in finding the epic within the everyday.

Davis’s own background also informs her perspective. Raised in poverty in Central Falls, Rhode Island, she has spoken candidly about the challenges and indignities she faced, experiences that have undoubtedly shaped her understanding of who deserves to be seen and heard. Her journey from these humble beginnings to the pinnacle of her profession, coupled with her unwavering commitment to authenticity in her roles, imbues her call to “exhume the ordinary” with a deep personal resonance. It is not an abstract artistic ideal for her, but a lived imperative.

In-Depth Analysis: The Power of “Exhuming the Ordinary”

Davis’s exhortation to “exhume the ordinary” is far more than a poetic turn of phrase; it is an active call to re-evaluate what constitutes compelling drama and who is deemed worthy of being its central figure. This concept can be broken down into several key components:

• Recognition and Validation: At its core, exhuming the ordinary is about providing recognition and validation to lives that have historically been marginalized or invisible. It means acknowledging the dignity, complexity, and inherent drama in the experiences of those who do not possess extraordinary power, wealth, or fame. This can range from the quiet heroism of a single parent working multiple jobs to the profound emotional landscape of a teenager navigating adolescence in a challenging environment. These are the lives that form the bedrock of society, yet their stories are too often left untold or are told through a distorted lens.
• Challenging Traditional Notions of Heroism: The traditional hero is often depicted as possessing exceptional abilities, overcoming external obstacles through sheer force or intellect, and achieving a definitive victory. Exhuming the ordinary shifts the focus to different forms of heroism. It highlights resilience in the face of adversity, the strength derived from community and love, the moral fortitude required to maintain integrity in compromised circumstances, and the quiet courage it takes to simply persevere. Davis’s portrayal of Rose Maxson is a prime example. Rose’s heroism is not in grand gestures, but in her enduring love, her sacrifices, and her eventual reclaiming of her own narrative, even within the confines of her life.
• Expanding the Cinematic Palate: By actively seeking out and amplifying the stories of ordinary people, filmmakers and storytellers broaden the entire spectrum of human experience that cinema can represent. This not only enriches the art form itself but also provides a more accurate and nuanced reflection of the world we inhabit. It moves beyond tropes and stereotypes to explore the rich tapestry of individual lives, revealing universal truths through specific, often overlooked, experiences. The relatability factor is amplified, fostering deeper connections between audiences and the characters on screen.
• The Importance of Authenticity and Nuance: “Exhuming the ordinary” demands a commitment to authenticity and nuance. It requires moving beyond superficial portrayals and delving into the psychological, emotional, and social intricacies of characters. This involves careful research, empathetic understanding, and a willingness to explore the messiness and contradictions inherent in human nature. It means not shying away from the difficult aspects of life, but embracing them as integral to the human experience.
• A Form of Social Justice: In many ways, exhuming the ordinary is an act of social justice. By giving voice and visibility to those who have been historically silenced or ignored, it challenges existing power structures and narratives. It asserts that every life has value and every story is worth telling. This is particularly relevant for marginalized communities, whose experiences are often filtered through the dominant cultural lens, leading to misrepresentation or erasure.

Davis’s own philosophy, as articulated in interviews and her public appearances, underscores these points. She has consistently emphasized the importance of finding the extraordinary within the ordinary, arguing that the lives of everyday people are filled with just as much drama, passion, and consequence as those of the traditionally celebrated. Her role in Fences, for instance, was lauded not just for her technical prowess but for her ability to unearth the deep emotional currents of a woman whose life was shaped by societal expectations and personal sacrifices. The speech itself, extending beyond her personal achievement, served as a powerful testament to the power of cinema to connect us through shared humanity, regardless of our backgrounds.

The impact of this philosophy extends beyond the screen. By championing these narratives, Davis inspires a new generation of actors, writers, and directors to look for stories in unexpected places. It encourages audiences to seek out films that reflect a broader range of human experience, thereby creating a demand that can fuel further change within the industry. The very act of valuing the ordinary can have a transformative effect on how we perceive ourselves and each other.

Pros and Cons: The Impact and Challenges of Advocating for the Ordinary

Viola Davis’s advocacy for “exhuming the ordinary” has undeniably brought numerous benefits to the film industry and broader cultural discourse, but like any significant artistic and social movement, it also faces inherent challenges:

Pros:

• Increased Representation and Inclusivity: The most significant positive outcome is the push for greater diversity both in front of and behind the camera. By highlighting the value of ordinary lives, Davis encourages the creation of stories featuring characters from all walks of life, including those from diverse racial, ethnic, socioeconomic, and gender backgrounds who have been historically underrepresented. This fosters a more inclusive cinematic landscape that mirrors the richness of the real world. The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences has made strides in inviting more diverse members, reflecting a broader industry push for representation.
• Enhanced Audience Connection and Empathy: Stories that resonate with the everyday experiences of audiences tend to foster deeper emotional connections and build empathy. When viewers see themselves, their families, or their communities reflected on screen with authenticity, it can lead to a greater understanding and appreciation of diverse perspectives. This is crucial for bridging cultural divides and promoting social cohesion.
• Artistic Innovation and Fresh Perspectives: Shifting the focus to the ordinary can lead to a wealth of new and innovative storytelling. It opens up opportunities for narratives that explore the subtle nuances of human relationships, the complexities of everyday struggles, and the quiet triumphs that often go unnoticed. This can revitalize filmmaking and push creative boundaries beyond established tropes.
• Challenging Stereotypes and Preconceptions: By presenting ordinary individuals with depth and complexity, these narratives can effectively challenge harmful stereotypes and preconceptions. They demonstrate that heroism, resilience, and profound emotional experience are not exclusive to the privileged or the extraordinary, but are inherent qualities found in people from all walks of life.
• Elevating the Craft of Acting: The art of portraying an ordinary person with authenticity and depth often requires immense skill and nuance. Davis’s advocacy shines a spotlight on the power of subtle performance, emotional honesty, and the ability to convey profound inner lives with restraint. This can elevate the appreciation for acting as a craft.

Cons:

• Perceived Lack of Spectacle or “Big” Moments: Some segments of the audience, conditioned to expect grand narratives and spectacular events, may find stories focused on ordinary lives to be less engaging or dramatic. The absence of overt action, high-stakes conflicts, or fantastical elements can be a hurdle for those seeking escapist entertainment.
• Commercial Viability Concerns: Historically, Hollywood studios have often been hesitant to invest heavily in films centered on “ordinary” characters, fearing they might not achieve the same broad commercial appeal as tentpole blockbusters. While this is changing, the pressure to produce profitable films can still lead to a preference for more conventional, widely marketable narratives. Box Office Mojo provides data on film financial performance, illustrating industry trends.
• Risk of Trivialization or Oversimplification: While the intent is to highlight the richness of ordinary lives, there is a risk that these stories could be poorly executed, leading to trivialization or oversimplification of complex issues. Authenticity and careful nuance are crucial to avoid portraying ordinary lives as mundane or unremarkable.
• The “Relatability” Trap: While relatability is a strength, an overemphasis on making characters universally relatable could inadvertently lead to a sanitization of experiences, particularly those rooted in specific cultural or social contexts. The goal should be to celebrate specificity while finding universal emotional truths.
• Navigating the “Ordinary” vs. “Extraordinary” Dichotomy: It’s important to acknowledge that there is still value in stories about extraordinary individuals and events. The challenge is not to erase these narratives but to ensure they exist in balance with and alongside the stories of the ordinary, and that the definition of “extraordinary” itself is broadened to include a wider range of human achievements and experiences.

The industry’s continued engagement with diversity initiatives, such as those promoted by organizations like Geena Davis Institute on Gender in Media, demonstrates an ongoing effort to address some of these challenges and promote more inclusive storytelling.

Key Takeaways

• The human element is paramount: Viola Davis’s call to “exhume the ordinary” emphasizes that the most compelling narratives are often found in the everyday experiences and emotional truths of relatable individuals.
• Redefining heroism: This perspective challenges traditional notions of heroism, highlighting resilience, perseverance, love, and integrity as potent forms of strength.
• Inclusivity is crucial: Elevating the stories of ordinary people inherently promotes greater representation and inclusivity within the film industry, reflecting a wider range of human experiences.
• Authenticity and nuance are key: Successfully portraying the ordinary requires a commitment to authentic storytelling and a nuanced exploration of characters’ inner lives and social contexts.
• Balancing commercial and artistic goals: While the commercial viability of ordinary-centric stories is a consideration, their artistic and social value is undeniable, driving innovation and deeper audience connection.
• An ongoing dialogue: Davis’s message is not a one-time statement but an ongoing call for a cultural shift in how we perceive and value human stories, encouraging continued dialogue and action within the entertainment industry and beyond.

Future Outlook: The Evolving Landscape of Cinematic Narratives

The future of filmmaking, influenced by voices like Viola Davis’s, appears to be moving towards a more expansive and inclusive understanding of what constitutes a compelling story. The increasing accessibility of filmmaking technology, coupled with the growth of diverse audiences demanding more representation, suggests a continued shift away from a singular, monolithic definition of cinematic success. We are likely to see:

• A greater emphasis on character-driven narratives: As audiences connect with relatable protagonists, the demand for films that prioritize character development and emotional depth over pure spectacle will likely grow. This will encourage more nuanced explorations of human psychology and relationships.
• Increased diversity in storytelling: The momentum towards greater representation of marginalized communities in film is expected to continue. This includes not only diverse casting but also the centering of diverse voices and perspectives in the writing and directing of films. Initiatives like Disney’s commitment to DEI reflect a broader industry trend.
• The rise of “quiet” cinema: Films that find their drama in the subtle moments, internal conflicts, and interpersonal dynamics of ordinary life may gain more traction, challenging the notion that only high-stakes, externally driven plots can engage audiences.
• Cross-cultural storytelling: As the world becomes more interconnected, we can anticipate more stories that explore the intersection of different cultures and the shared humanity that transcends cultural boundaries.
• Empowerment of independent filmmakers: The growth of independent film and streaming platforms will continue to provide vital avenues for filmmakers to tell stories that might not fit within the traditional studio system, often focusing on the very “ordinary” lives Davis champions. Organizations supporting independent film, such as Sundance Institute, play a crucial role in this ecosystem.

However, the industry will still need to navigate the inherent tension between artistic integrity and commercial pressures. Ensuring that the pursuit of profitability does not lead to a dilution of authentic storytelling will be an ongoing challenge. The success of films that have embraced Davis’s philosophy, like Minari or Nomadland, suggests that audiences are indeed receptive to these kinds of narratives when they are executed with skill and heart. The continued exploration of these themes by acclaimed directors like Chloé Zhao further signals a promising direction for cinema.

Call to Action: Embracing the Extraordinary in the Everyday

Viola Davis’s powerful words at the Oscars were not just an acceptance speech; they were an invitation. An invitation to re-examine our own biases about what makes a life, and therefore a story, worth telling. An invitation to look beyond the sensational and find the profound in the familiar.

For filmmakers and storytellers, the call to action is clear: actively seek out and champion narratives that delve into the lives of ordinary people. Invest in diverse voices and perspectives. Be bold in exploring the quiet dramas and subtle triumphs that shape our collective human experience. Remember the power of authenticity and the impact of seeing oneself reflected in art.

For audiences, the call to action is equally important: support films that embrace this ethos. Seek out movies that may not have the biggest budgets or the most explosive special effects, but that offer genuine human connection and insight. Engage with these stories, discuss them, and let your viewing choices signal to the industry that there is a significant appetite for the richness of ordinary lives.

Ultimately, “exhuming the ordinary” is about recognizing that the most extraordinary thing we can do is to truly see and understand one another. It is about celebrating the resilience, the love, the struggles, and the quiet dignity that define the human spirit, not just in the grand moments, but in the everyday. Viola Davis has given us a powerful lens through which to view our world and the stories within it. It is now up to all of us to embrace that vision and ensure that every life, in its magnificent ordinariness, has the chance to be heard and to shine.